Foods compared by label data: compare foods

Best Training Treats for Labs (and How Many to Give)

Updated · Sources are cited in the text

Best Training Treats for Labs (and How Many to Give)

General nutrition information compiled from product labels and published sources, not veterinary advice. Your veterinarian is the right person to choose a diet for your dog, especially one with a health condition.

Labradors work hard for food, which makes treats a useful training tool. It also makes them an easy way to overfeed. This guide covers how to pick the best treats for labs, how small to make them, and how to count them so the daily total stays reasonable.

We compared general treat categories and label data. We did not run taste tests or feeding trials, and we are not ranking brands here.

Why treat choice matters for a Lab

The Labrador Retriever Club's breed standard describes adult males at roughly 65 to 80 pounds and females at roughly 55 to 70 pounds, in working condition. A dog that size can gain extra weight quietly, one handful of rewards at a time.

Food motivation is also a real feature of the breed. A 2016 study in Cell Metabolism (Raffan et al.), listed by the MRC Epidemiology Unit, reported a deletion in the POMC gene in 12 percent of the Labradors studied. The study linked this to food motivation and weight. It was more common in assistance dogs than in pets. Many Labs are eager eaters without any gene change, but it is a good reason to count treats.

Whether an individual dog needs a particular diet or weight plan is a question for your veterinarian.

What you need

  • Two or three treat types from different categories (see below).
  • A small cutting board and a knife, or a pair of kitchen scissors.
  • A kitchen scale or a measuring spoon, to portion treats.
  • A treat pouch or small container for training sessions.
  • The calorie figure from each treat label. Many labels print it as kcal per treat or kcal per kilogram.
  • Your dog's daily calorie target from your veterinarian, or the feeding guide on your dog's food as a starting point.
  • Your dog's regular food, which you can use as part of the reward supply.

The three treat categories worth knowing

Soft training treats

These are moist, easy to break apart, and quick to swallow. That makes them handy for fast repetition. Check the label for a calorie statement and read the ingredient list top to bottom. Soft treats can be calorie dense, so break them down further than you think you need to.

Freeze-dried single protein treats

These contain one animal protein, such as one type of meat. A short ingredient list makes them easy to read, and they are useful if you are watching for ingredients your dog does not tolerate. They are often strongly scented, so they work well for high-value moments, like recall practice around distractions. They crumble easily, so tear them into small pieces.

Vegetables

Some dogs accept plain vegetable pieces as rewards. Check with your veterinarian about which ones suit your dog, and introduce any new food in small amounts. Vegetables are usually lower in calories per piece than commercial treats, which is why some owners use them for low-stakes repetitions. Skip anything seasoned, salted or cooked in oil.

No category is automatically the best. The best treats for labs are the ones your dog will work for, that you can portion tiny, and that fit inside the daily calorie budget.

Step by step: choosing and portioning labrador retriever treats

Step 1: Find your dog's daily calorie target

Ask your veterinarian for a daily calorie amount for your dog. Without one, use the feeding guide on the food bag as a starting point. Feeding guides are starting points only. Hill's, for example, tells owners to adjust amounts to maintain optimal weight and to ask a veterinarian if unsure. Activity, age and body condition all change what a dog needs.

Step 2: Apply the 10 percent rule

A widely repeated guideline, including in the World Small Animal Veterinary Association (WSAVA) calorie guidance, is to keep treats to about 10 percent of daily calories. The rest should come from a complete and balanced main diet. Check the WSAVA guidance or ask your veterinarian how it applies to your dog.

Here is the arithmetic, using made-up numbers purely as an illustration. If a dog's daily target were 1,000 kcal, treats would top out near 100 kcal for the day. That is not a recommendation for any real dog.

Step 3: Read the treat label

Find the kcal per treat, or convert from kcal per kilogram using the weight of the pieces you plan to give. Then divide your treat allowance by that number. This gives you the number of treats for the day. A treat that looks small can still carry a surprising amount of calories.

Step 4: Cut treats down to pea size or smaller

Treat size for a Lab should be small, roughly a pea or a small fingernail. The dog gets the reward, the session keeps moving, and you can give many more repetitions for the same calories. Large treats slow down training and use up the budget fast. Labs often gulp rewards whole anyway, so a larger piece adds calories without adding enjoyment.

Step 5: Count out the day's treats in advance

Every morning, put the day's treat allowance in a container. When it is empty, treats are done, unless you swap in part of the dog's regular kibble. Counting ahead of time is the simplest way to stop a pocketful from turning into a bowlful.

Step 6: Use kibble for easy repetitions

Set aside part of the regular meal for training. Use it for simple behaviors your dog already knows, such as a sit in the kitchen. Save the better treats for harder work. Since this food counts toward the same daily total, subtract it from the meal rather than adding it on top. Our label-by-label dog food comparison lists calories per cup for several foods, which helps with the subtraction.

Step 7: Reward quickly and with a clear marker

Deliver the treat within a second or two of the behavior you want. Use a short marker word such as "yes," then reward. Reward-based training, the approach supported by the American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior (AVSAB), relies on this timing. Never use punishment-based tools or methods to compensate for a lack of treats.

Step 8: Taper the treats as the behavior improves

Once a behavior is reliable, reward it every few repetitions rather than every time. Mix in praise, a toy or a favorite activity. Keep some rewards unpredictable so your dog keeps trying.

Tips for better results

  • Keep sessions short, a few minutes at a time, so your dog is still hungry for the work.
  • Train before meals when it suits your dog. A slightly hungry Lab is usually more attentive.
  • Rotate treat types so one never becomes boring.
  • Keep a log of treats for a week. Most owners are surprised by the total.
  • Introduce any new treat slowly and watch how your dog's stool and skin respond. Contact your veterinarian if something seems off.
  • If your dog is a puppy, ask your veterinarian before changing the diet. Large-size puppies need a growth food labeled for large-size dogs, and extra calcium from supplements is not recommended. Treats should stay a small part of the day.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Counting only the "official" treats. Chews, dental sticks, table scraps and food used to hide pills all add calories.
  • Using big pieces. Bigger does not mean better to a Lab. Tiny pieces work just as well in most sessions.
  • Not adjusting meals on heavy training days. If treats climb, trim the meal by a matching amount.
  • Treating every family member differently. Everyone in the house should follow the same treat budget, or the count falls apart.
  • Assuming a treat is healthy because it sounds natural. Read the calorie statement and ingredient list instead of the front of the bag.
  • Trusting a treat's marketing claims about health. No treat prevents or treats joint problems, allergies or heart disease. Hip and elbow dysplasia are on the Labrador Retriever Club's list of recommended health clearances, and the club's health page gives no diet guidance for them. Take those questions to your veterinarian.
  • Skipping vet advice on weight. If your Lab is gaining, ask your veterinarian to check body condition and set a plan.

What to expect

With small, well-timed rewards, many Labs learn simple behaviors such as sit, down and come within a few weeks of regular short sessions. Results vary with the dog's age, history and the setting. Counting treats may also make it easier to keep your dog at a steady weight, though body condition depends on the whole diet and activity level.

If your dog is gaining weight despite counting, or is losing interest in food, talk to your veterinarian rather than making large changes on your own.

Quick reference

Treat typeBest useWatch for
Soft training treatsFast repetitions, new skillsCalories add up; break them small
Freeze-dried single proteinHigh-value moments, distractionsCrumbles; strong smell
VegetablesLow-stakes practiceAsk your vet which ones suit your dog; keep them plain
Part of regular kibbleEasy, known behaviorsSubtract it from the meal

Sources